Where to Stay in Anna Maria Island, Florida (TOP Places + Amazing Hotels in 2025)

Anna Maria Island might just be the coolest beach paradise in the United States! With its stunning white sand beaches, charming Old Florida-style beach houses, delicious seafood, and the amazing perk of not needing a car, it’s a total dream destination.

When I first visited Anna Maria Island in 2019, I was hooked. One of the things I loved most is that you can walk just about everywhere. Want to head to the beach? It’s just a stroll away. Craving breakfast or a coffee? The cutest little coffee shop is probably right down the road. That walkable vibe gives the whole island this relaxed, small-town beach community feel, and honestly, it’s such a refreshing change. It reminded me of the laid-back charm you’d find in the Caribbean, but hey, it’s right here in Florida—and I think that’s pretty awesome!

Even though Anna Maria Island is small, it’s long and skinny, which means choosing where to stay is a bit of a thing. You’ll want to make sure you’re in the right spot to make the most of your trip.

So, let’s dive into my recommendations for where to stay in Anna Maria Island.

How to Get to Anna Maria Island

Getting to Anna Maria Island is simple and stress-free. If you’re not driving from nearby, you’ll likely need to fly. There are two main airport options: Sarasota Bradenton International Airport and Tampa International Airport.

Sarasota Bradenton International is just 30 minutes from Anna Maria Island, making it the closest option. You can easily grab an Uber to the island, but keep in mind that it’s a smaller airport and flights here are often more expensive.

Tampa International Airport is a more budget-friendly choice and only about an hour’s drive from the island. As a larger airport, it offers a wide range of airlines and plenty of car rental options, giving you more flexibility for your trip.

We usually fly into Tampa International Airport and then either rent a car or book one of the shuttle services that take you to Anna Maria Island.

► Click here for our full guide on How to Get to Anna Maria Island

When Is the Best Time to Visit Anna Maria Island ?

The best time to visit Anna Maria Island is from April through November when the weather is warm and sunny. However, this also coincides with peak tourist season, so you can expect larger crowds and higher prices during this time.

If you want to beat the crowds and save some money, consider visiting in December through March. While temperatures may be cooler (by Florida standards), the island still sees plenty of sunshine.

We often visit in November or December just because it’s way less busy but still great for the beach.

Where Is the Best Place to Stay on Anna Maria Island?

Are you wondering where to stay on Anna Maria Island and which hotel to book? Here are my favorite spots!

Best Anna Maria Island Hotels

Mello on the Beach – Best Boutique Hotel in Anna Maria Island

This boutique hotel on the beach is my top recommendation if you’re looking to stay at the coolest spot on Anna Maria Island. It has a nostalgic, old-school beach vibe that I absolutely love. The design is unique and perfect for capturing some amazing photos. With a heated pool and its location just a short walk from the beach, it’s an ideal choice for a relaxing beach vacation.

► Click here for more information & bookings

Bungalow Beach Resort – Best Vacation Rentals in Anna Maria Island

This is my top choice for anyone traveling with a group of friends or family who wants some privacy. Bungalow Beach Resort offers charming private townhouses with private beach access. I loved staying here because we visited with the whole family, making breakfast together in the morning and heading straight to the beach afterward. That’s one of the perks of having a fully equipped townhouse with a kitchen and living room.

► Click here for more information & bookings

The Retreat at Anna Maria Island Inn – Best Hotel in Anna Maria Island

This charming retreat at Anna Maria Island Inn is both cute and affordable. It’s just a short walk from the beach, features mini golf, and is one of the few pet-friendly hotels on Anna Maria Island. It also offers an outdoor swimming pool. When we visited, we rented a golf cart and explored the entire island—it was such a fun experience!

► Click here for more information & bookings

Anna Maria Island Neighborhood Guide – Best Places to Stay on Anna Maria Island

Anna Maria Island, located on Florida’s Gulf Coast, is a gem filled with beautiful beaches, great food, and luxurious accommodations. The island is small and narrow, so choosing the right neighborhood to stay in can really make a difference.

The island is divided into three main communities: Anna Maria City, Holmes Beach, and Bradenton Beach. All three are fantastic, but we usually stay in the North Beach Village area, which is part of Anna Maria City. It’s quiet, charming, and super convenient.

Getting around the island is easy. The simplest option? Walk! If you’re staying in a central spot like North Beach Village, you can easily reach everything you need on foot. If you want to see more of the island, rent a car or a golf cart to explore.

Anna Maria Island also offers free public transportation with the Anna Maria Island Trolley. It runs the length of the island, stopping at all the popular spots. It’s an easy, stress-free way to get around without worrying about parking or directions.

If you’re visiting Anna Maria Island for the first time and prefer walking over driving, my top recommendation is Anna Maria City.

Holmes Beach, located in the center of the island, is a great choice if you want to be in the heart of the action. It’s full of restaurants, bars with live music, and hotels offering beachfront views.

Lastly, I recommend Bradenton Beach, located at the southern end of Anna Maria Island. It’s a bit quieter, which I love, but you’ll likely need a car to explore the area if you stay here.

Anna Maria Island’s 3 Best Neighborhoods

In this next section, I’ll give you more information about the three communities/neighborhoods of Anna Maria Island. We’ll dive into what the areas are like, a few things to do, and I’ll also share some of my favorite hotel recommendations.

Anna Maria – Where to Stay in Anna Maria Island for the First Time

The north end of Anna Maria Island, known as Anna Maria (City), is a laid-back, charming area filled with stunning beaches, quaint streets and alleyways, swaying palm trees, and classic Old Florida-style beach cottages and homes.

It’s my favorite spot on the island, which is why I highly recommend staying here if it’s your first visit.

At the heart of the area is Pine Avenue, a delightful high street with cozy coffee shops, great restaurants, and unique boutique stores. Everything is conveniently within walking distance—from the beach to the northern tip of the island.

If you’re in the mood to explore further, simply hop on the trolley and head south to see more of what the island has to offer.

Batemans – Best Vacation Rentals for Families

This is my top recommendation for a large family or a big group of friends. We stayed here one year with the whole family, and it was so much fun. For a start, the house is stunning with an outdoor pool, but it also has a dock, sun terrace, foosball table, and loads of other activities.

► Click here for more information & bookings

Shore Bet – Best Holiday Home in Anna Maria

Very similar to the accommodation above is Shore Bet. This holiday home is also perfect for larger groups. They have a super cool outdoor area with a swimming pool and BBQ area. They also have their own dock and private mini golf/putting green, which some of the guys really enjoyed.

Click here for more information & bookings

South Bay Inn – Best Budget Stay in Anna Maria

This little apartment is much more affordable. Located just a short walk from the beach, it’s perfect for a couple or a small family. The interior is newly renovated and has everything you need for a comfortable stay. Plus, they provide bikes for guests to use, which is a great way to explore the island.

► Click here for more information & bookings

Things to do in Anna Maria City

• Visit the Beach: Check out Bean Point Beach for sunsets and Bayfront Park for a great family beach.
• Explore Pine Avenue: My favorite spots here are North Shore Cafe for the best coffee and breakfast in town, and Poppo’s Taqueria for my favorite tacos.
• Go Fishing: Try your hand at fishing on the historic Anna Maria City Pier.
• Rent a Bike or Golf Cart: Cruise around the island in true laid-back style.
• Take a Sunset Cruise: Enjoy breathtaking views and spot dolphins along the way.

►Click Here for our Guide to the Best Beaches in Anna Maria Island

Holmes Beach – The Best place to Stay For Families & Exploring

Holmes Beach is right in the middle of Anna Maria Island. I’ve only stayed here once, but I really enjoyed it. It’s definitely busier and louder than other areas, but that also means there’s more to do.

The beach here, Manatee Public Beach, gets super crowded during high season, but I totally get why. It’s a white sand beach with plenty of space and crystal-clear water. There are showers, restrooms, and changing rooms, and just behind the beach, you’ll find loads of shops and restaurants. If you’re traveling with family, it’s a great spot because it has everything you need.

In the town center, there are tons of restaurants and bars, and some of them are my absolute favorites. The Ugly Grouper is my go-to for a post-beach lunch, a cold beer, and live music.

Waterline Villas & Marina – Best Luxury Hotel in Anna Maria Island

Waterline Villas is one of the top luxury addresses in Anna Maria. It is located on Holmes Beach, and as soon as I walked into the lobby, I was blown away by the modern and chic design. The apartments are spacious and beautifully furnished, with fully equipped kitchens perfect for a longer stay or for families.

► Click here for more information & bookings

Mainsail Beach Inn – Best Luxury Hotel in Anna Maria Island

Mainsail Beach Inn is the sister property to Waterline Villas and offers a similar level of luxury and comfort. Located on the quieter north end of the island, this boutique hotel is perfect for couples or those looking for a peaceful retreat. The rooms are beautifully designed with coastal-inspired decor, and the private beach access adds an extra touch of exclusivity.

► Click here for more information & bookings

Anna Maria Beach Resort – Best Resort on Anna Maria Island

My favorite beach resort on Anna Maria Island is the Anna Maria Beach Resort. This newly renovated property offers spacious, modern rooms with stunning views of the Gulf of Mexico. The resort also has a beachfront pool and hot tub, perfect for relaxing after a day at the beach.

► Click here for more information & bookings

Bradenton Beach – The Best Place to Stay on Anna Maria Island on a Budget

The southern part of Anna Maria Island is home to Bradenton Beach, a more laid-back area compared to the rest of the island, making it an excellent choice for budget travelers. Here, you’ll find some of the best and most affordable accommodations on the island, including charming beach cottages and cozy vacation rental homes.

Bradenton Beach also offers a great selection of budget-friendly restaurants, serving delicious seafood and other local favorites. Be sure to visit Bridge Street Pier and grab some oysters from the Anna Maria Oyster Bar!

In addition to its relaxed vibe and affordability, Bradenton Beach features stunning beaches with pristine white sand and crystal-clear waters. Honestly, I love all the Gulf beaches on the island!

Silver Surf Gulf Beach Resort – Best Cheap Resort in Anna Maria Island

One of the best budget-friendly resorts in Bradenton Beach is the Silver Surf Gulf Beach Resort. This beachfront property offers comfortable and spacious rooms with stunning views of the Gulf of Mexico. Furthermore, it has a heated pool and direct access to the beach.

► Click here for more information & bookings

Cedar Cove Resort & Cottages – Best Beach Front Hotel

If you’re looking for a more intimate and private accommodation option, Cedar Cove Resort & Cottages is the perfect choice. This charming beachfront hotel offers cozy cottages with full kitchens, perfect for families or couples on a budget. You can also enjoy the resort’s private beach area and complimentary use of kayaks and paddleboards.

► Click here for more information & bookings

Things to do in Bradenton Beach

• Cruise along Gulf Drive on an electric bike and discover stunning beaches
• Take a guided manatee tour for an unforgettable experience – Click here
• Paddle into the sunset with a dolphin kayak tour – Click Here

FAQ on Where to Stay on Anna Maria Island

Can I find a hotel with a heated pool on Anna Maria Island?

Yes, many hotels and resorts on Anna Maria Island offer heated pools for guests to enjoy year-round. Some even feature multiple heated pools for added convenience and comfort.

Is it necessary to rent a car on Anna Maria Island?

Renting a car on Anna Maria Island is not necessary, as most attractions and amenities are easily accessible by walking, biking, or using the free trolley. However, if you plan to explore other areas of Florida during your stay, having a rental car could be helpful.

Are there any kid-friendly activities on the island?

Absolutely! Anna Maria Island offers plenty of kid-friendly activities. Popular options include visiting the Mote Marine Laboratory and Aquarium, playing mini-golf at The Fish Hole, or going on a family-friendly dolphin tour.

Our Final Thoughts on Where to Stay on Anna Maria Island

Anna Maria Island is the perfect spot for a relaxing getaway with a laid-back vibe. Whether you’re dreaming of a luxury beachfront resort or a cozy beach cottage, there’s something here for every style and budget. Think about your ideal location, budget, and must-have amenities when picking your place to stay. Wherever you choose, you’ll be close to breathtaking beaches and unforgettable moments on Anna Maria Island.

Related Articles