Where To Stay in Caye Caulker: My Ultimate Guide to the TOP 11 Hotels on the Island (2025)

Last Updated on April 5, 2025 by Oliver

Before heading to the island you should know that Caye Caulker is tiny. At just 1.5 square miles, the whole island is walkable, and with no cars (just golf carts and bikes), life moves at an easy, sun-soaked pace. But don’t let the size fool you—where you stay can make or break your trip.

When we booked our trip, we didn’t overthink it. Classic last-minute move. The first place we stayed was way down south in the local neighborhood. Super chill, but the 25-minute walk in the Caribbean sun was brutal. After a few days of sweating our way to town, we bailed and moved to a cute bungalow right in the middle of the island and it was perfect. Close to everything, but far enough from The Split to actually sleep at night.

If you’re heading to Caye Caulker, you’ll want to lock in your spot early—good places disappear fast. That’s where this guide on Where to Stay in Caye Caulker comes in. Whether you’re looking for boutique vibes, budget stays, or something right on the water, these 11 places to stay got you covered. Let’s get into it!

Best Area to Stay in Caye Caulker

North Island vs. South Island

Before getting into the best hotels, let’s talk about the layout of Caye Caulker—and set some expectations. This isn’t the kind of island with different neighborhoods and districts. It’s split into two sections: the North Island and the South Island, divided by The Split. Each has a different vibe, but for most travelers, one side just makes way more sense.

South Island: Where Everything Happens

This is where we stayed, and honestly, we had everything we needed. Restaurants, bars, tour operators, dive shops—it was all right there. We actually never even went to the North Island because it wasn’t necessary. If you’re looking for the best mix of convenience, fun, and easy access to the island’s highlights, this is the place to stay.

While the South Island doesn’t have defined neighborhoods, there are a few different areas to choose from:

• On the water – The dream spot. If you want a stay with ocean views and easy beach access, this is it.
• In the local neighborhoods – A more authentic experience, usually quieter and more budget-friendly. We stayed in this area at first, and while it had a great local feel, the long walk to town wasn’t ideal.
• Near The Split & town – The best spot if you want to be close to the action. Just know it gets loud, especially at night.

North Island: Remote & Secluded

The North Island is quieter, more remote, and mostly home to high-end resorts and vacation rentals. There are fewer restaurants and bars, so you’ll need a bike or water taxi to get around. Some people love the seclusion, but personally, we never felt the need to go over there.

So, Where’s the Best Area to Stay?

If you want the best experience in Caye Caulker, stay on the South Island. It’s got the best mix of hotels, food, and activities, and you won’t waste time or money on water taxis.

Now that you know the layout, let’s get into the TOP 11 hotels in Caye Caulker!

11 Best Places to Stay in Caye Caulker Belize

Colinda Cabanas// Best Hotel in Caye Caulker

If you look at any list of where to stay in Caye Caulker, Colinda Cabanas is bound to show up, and for good reason. This place is the spot on the island—cute, affordable, and right on the sandy beach. Seriously, if you can score one of these cabanas, consider yourself one of God’s favorites.

These little tropical dreams are painted in bright yellow and blue, making them instantly Instagram-worthy. Located in a quiet area of the island, you get the peaceful vibes without feeling totally removed. Plus, they offer free bikes so you can easily pedal your way into town for food, drinks, or a little sightseeing.

The Cabanas come with a fully equipped kitchen, A/C, and free drinking water to keep you comfortable throughout your stay.

💡Check out the best things to do in Caye Caulker once you arrive!

Weezie’s Ocean Front Hotel & Garden Cottages// Upscale Caye Caulker Accommodation

If you’re after aesthetic, beachfront perfection, Weezie’s Ocean Front Hotel is the move. Unlike a lot of places on Caye Caulker that lean more homey or rustic, this one feels like a boutique escape. The design is beautiful, the property is well-maintained, and the oceanfront views are top-tier.

It’s a bit of a walk from the main town area, which means peace and quiet, but they have bikes for rent if you don’t feel like hoofing it. With a pool, private dock, and modern, stylish rooms, Weezie’s is one of the prettiest places to stay on the island—perfect for couples or anyone wanting a chill, comfortable stay with a bit of an upscale feel.

Dream Cabanas// Best Value Hotel in Caye Caulker

Though we didn’t stay here because it was sold out, Dream Cabanas is hands down one of the best value-for-money options on the island. This place offers a fantastic balance of comfort, privacy, and affordability. Located in a quiet area, it’s just a 5–10 minute walk from the main attractions, so you’re never far from the action, but still far enough to enjoy some peace and quiet.

Each of the six rooms comes equipped with A/C, a fan, a mini-fridge, and a private bathroom with a step-in shower. The property is impeccably clean, well-maintained, and peaceful, with a friendly staff always ready to assist.

If you’re looking for a budget-friendly option that doesn’t skimp on amenities, Dream Cabanas is definitely a top contender.

Treetops Hotel// Best Place to Stay in Caye Caulker with a Swimming Pool

Treetops Hotel is located at the quieter southern end of Caye Caulker, just a six-minute walk from the ferry terminal. The rooms here are bright, airy, and spacious, offering a relaxing atmosphere. Each room is well-equipped with a fridge, TV, safe, fan, and A/C to keep things comfortable.

The hotel has excellent amenities, including a swimming pool, lots of lounge areas, and a rooftop terrace with great views. For beach lovers, there’s a private beach right across the road and when you want to explore the island you can borrow their free bicycles.

Bay Towers// Best Hotel on The North Side of Caye Caulker

If you’re looking to stay on the North Island, Bay Towers is your best bet. This condo-style hotel is perfect for a romantic getaway, offering a prime location right on the crystal-clear waters of the beach. The views are absolutely stunning, and the whole place exudes a relaxed, tranquil vibe.

The hotel is just a 5-minute walk from The Split, and you’ll never wait more than 2-3 minutes for the ferry, which makes it easy to hop between the North and South islands. Plus, with the clip card for the ferry, each crossing is only about $1.50—a great deal for easy access to both sides of the island.

Staying here gives you the best of both worlds: the peace and quiet of the North Island while still being a quick hop from the South’s livelier areas.

Seaside Villas// Best Place to Stay in Caye Caulker for Families or Groups

If you’re after a little more space and privacy, Seaside Villas is an excellent choice. Just a 2-minute walk from the ferry, it’s super convenient for anyone traveling with rolling suitcases or who wants quick access to the island’s main areas.

The villas are spacious and come with a fully equipped kitchen, making it easy to settle in and feel right at home. Plus, the gorgeous rooftop offers stunning views of the island and is the perfect place to relax and enjoy the sunset after a day of exploring. (The sunsets on the other side of the island, but it’s still beautiful.)

This spot is ideal for families or small groups who want a bit more room than a typical hotel room.

The Novela// Best Budget Stay in Caye Caulker

If you’re looking for affordable comfort with a touch of local hospitality, The Novelo is a fantastic option. Located on the south side of the island, it’s a bit removed from the hustle, offering a quieter, more laid-back atmosphere. Abel, the owner, is a legend—he’ll pick you up from the ferry in his golf cart and even has bikes available for you to borrow if you’d rather bike into town than walk.

The rooms are simple but spacious, with air-conditioning, Wi-Fi, and a private bathroom. You also get access to a pool—a nice touch for cooling off after a long day of exploring.

It’s perfect for budget travelers who want to experience the island without splurging. That said, if you’re solo and prefer being close to the action, the location might feel a bit far from town. Still, if you’re up for a short bike ride or walk, it’s a great, wallet-friendly option!

Sea Dreams Hotel// Our Favorite Caye Caulker Hotel!!

On our second stay in Caye Caulker, we lucked out with a last-minute cancellation at Sea Dreams Hotel—and wow, did we hit the jackpot. This family-run hotel is beautifully located on the west coast with its own private beachfront area for sunbathing and swimming, plus a rooftop terrace where they serve a homemade breakfast that changes daily (and is absolutely delicious).

The two-bedroom apartment we stayed in was spacious and cozy, with classic Caribbean-style decor that made it feel even more homey. While it’s not the most modern aesthetic, it just adds to the charm.

Beyond the great location and comfort, the staff is amazing. Anna and the team go above and beyond, and they even offer free canoes, paddleboards, and bikes to explore the island. We didn’t want to leave—and honestly, we’re already plotting a return.

Bellas Backpacker// Best Place to Stay in Caye Caulker as a Backpacker

Alright, I’m gonna be honest—I probably wouldn’t stay at Bella’s Backpackers, but that’s because I’m 30 and past my “sweating in a cramped dorm” phase. But if you’re a young backpacker on a tight budget and looking for a super social, party-friendly vibe, this place could be a solid choice.

It’s basic, it’s hot, and it’s definitely not for light sleepers, but it’s one of the cheapest options on the island and a great spot to meet other travelers. If you’re down for hammocks, no-frills accommodations, and a lively atmosphere, you’ll probably have a blast. Just know what you’re signing up for—because this is definitely not a luxury stay.

💡You can’t miss these local eats once you’re in Caye Caulker!

Island Magic Beach Resort // Best Caye Caulker Resort

If you’re looking for a comfortable, beachfront stay with a little extra charm, Island Magic Villas is a great pick. It’s right on the water, with a pool, on site restaurant, swim-up bar, and private beach area—basically, everything you need for a laid-back, tropical vacation.

The location is super central, within walking distance from restaurants, beach bars, and the ferry, so you’re never far from the action. The rooms are spacious, clean, and well-equipped, making it a solid mid-range option for those who want more comfort than a basic guesthouse but without the luxury price tag. If you’re all about easy beach access and a relaxed vibe, this one’s worth checking out!

Blue Wave Guest House

If you’re looking for a budget-friendly stay that doesn’t feel like a total dive, Blue Wave Guest House is a solid pick. Rooms start at under $40 a night, making it one of the best-value stays on Caye Caulker. It’s right by the water, so you still get those island views without the hefty price tag.

BUT—be super careful when booking. Not all rooms have A/C, and personally, a fan is just not enough on this island unless you love waking up in a puddle of your own sweat. If you can snag an air-conditioned room, though, this is a great option for budget travelers who just need a place to crash after a day of exploring.

Thinking about diving? Check out my review of Sunrise Scuba and the dives I did in Caye Caulker!

FAQ: Everything You Need to Know about Hotels in Caye Caulker

How to Get to Caye Caulker from Belize City?

The easiest way to get to Caye Caulker is by water taxi. I took the San Pedro Belize Express Water Taxi, which was about 45 minutes and super easy. A one-way ticket costs around $20, but getting a round-trip for $37 saves a bit. If you’re short on time (or just really love tiny planes), you can also fly with Tropic Air or Maya Island Air—it’s only a 15-minute flight, but way more expensive.

Where to Stay in Caye Caulker on the Beach?

If you want to wake up with ocean views, Sea Dreams Hotel is a fantastic pick. It’s got a private dock, which makes it easy to swim or sunbathe without the crowds.Weezie’s Ocean Front Hotelis another solid option—it actually feels like a boutique hotel, which is rare for Caye Caulker. If you’re traveling with family, Island Magic Beach Resort is one of the best beachfront hotels Caye Caulker has.

Best Cheap Hotels in Caye Caulker?

If you’re on a budget,Blue Wave Guest House is a steal at under $40 a night—just be careful when booking because some rooms don’t have A/C, and personally, a fan isn’t cutting it on this island. The Novela is another great budget-friendly stay. It’s further south, but Abel, the owner, picks you up from the ferry in a golf cart and has bikes you can borrow to get into town. If you want a more social vibe, Bella’s Backpackers is a classic backpacker spot, though I’ll be honest—at 30, I’ve outgrown dorm rooms that feel like saunas.

Which Side of Caye Caulker is Best?

For me, South Island is the best spot to stay. This is where all the restaurants, bars, and tour shops are, so it’s perfect if you want to be close to the action. If you’re looking for something quieter, the North Island is beautiful and more secluded, but you’ll need to take a boat to get to town. It’s great for couples or anyone looking for a more off-the-grid experience.

Final Thoughts on Where to Stay in Caye Caulker

If you’re planning a trip to Caye Caulker, I hope all our tips help you find the perfect place to stay! Personally, I don’t think you can go wrong with Colinda Cabanas for an affordable, beachfront stay or Sea Dreams Hotel, which completely won us over with its rooftop breakfasts and private dock. No matter where you stay, you’re in for an unforgettable island escape.

Related Articles