Where to Stay in Siesta Key Florida: 14 Best Hotels & Areas

When we first arrived in Siesta Key, we were immediately struck by how different it felt compared to many other spots in Florida. The powdery sand, the laid-back atmosphere, and the clear blue waters made it the perfect place to relax and forget about the world. Whether you’re visiting for the first time or you’re a Siesta Key regular, there’s something about this place that keeps pulling you back.

Choosing where to stay on Siesta Key can be a bit tricky, though — the island has a few distinct areas, each with its own personality and perks.

One big reason why we loved Siesta Key is that it’s not as popular or expensive as Anna Maria Island. It’s not necessarily a budget option, but the beach resorts here are much more affordable. We’ll give you some tips on the best budget options, as well as the best areas for families and first-time visitors.

In this guide, we’ll walk you through the best areas to stay in Siesta Key so you can find the perfect spot that feels just right for you.

Where to Stay in Siesta Key Florida?

The Residences on Siesta Key Beach // Best Luxury Hotel in Siesta Key

►Click here for more information & bookings

Turtle Beach Resort // Best Cheap Resort in Siesta Key

If you’re looking for a home away from home, Turtle Beach Resort is the perfect choice. The villas are spacious and well-equipped, making them a great option for families or friends traveling together. With a pool, BBQ, patio, beach chairs, and hammocks, it’s the perfect spot to relax and unwind for the week.

►Click here for more information & bookings

Kompose Boutique Hotel Sarasota // Best Boutique Hotel in Siesta Key

The newest and most modern boutique hotel on the island, Kompose offers a unique experience for guests. With stylish rooms and a rooftop bar and lounge, it’s perfect for couples or solo travelers seeking a luxurious stay. I love the hotel’s minimalist style—it’s definitely a refreshing change from the vintage Florida look of most places, and it’s super cool.

►Click here for more information & bookings

Siesta Key Area Guide – Best Places to Stay in Siesta Key Florida

Siesta Key Beach

If you’re visiting Siesta Key for the first time, Siesta Key Beach is the place to be. The soft, powdery sand, the gentle waves, and the laid-back vibe are exactly what you came for. We stayed here on our first visit, and it quickly became our favorite spot. Being so close to the beach and everything else really made it easy to settle in and just enjoy the simple joys of Siesta Key.

Siesta Key Village

For those of us who love a little nightlife with our beach days, Siesta Key Village is the spot. It’s a fun, easygoing area with lively bars, local eateries, and cute little shops—basically the downtown area of the island—all within walking distance of Siesta Key Beach. We ended up spending a lot of our evenings here, grabbing dinner, popping into a bar for live music, or just strolling around.

Siesta Key’s Crescent Beach

If you’re traveling with kids or just want a quieter spot to hang out, Crescent Beach feels like paradise. The vibe here is so much more peaceful, and it’s perfect for families who want to enjoy the beauty of Siesta Key without the crowds. The shallow waters are perfect for little ones, and we loved how easy it was to just spread out and relax. We also thought it would be great for a romantic weekend or for couples since it’s so quiet here.

Sarasota

I know it’s not on Siesta Key at all, but when we were looking for more budget-friendly options, Sarasota became our go-to. It’s just a short drive from Siesta Key and offers a variety of affordable places to stay without losing that Siesta Key charm. We found some great little inns and vacation rentals in Sarasota, and it ended up being the perfect base for exploring the island while keeping things easy on the wallet. Honestly, it’s so close to Siesta Key that it’s well worth staying there and driving over to the island.

💡Looking for the Best Spots for Your Next Spring Break Holiday? Check Out our Guide on The Best Spring Break Destinations!

1.Siesta Key Beach – Best Place to Stay in Siesta Key for the First Time

If it’s your first time visiting Siesta Key, staying near Siesta Beach is the way to go. This area is where you’ll find a lot of the island’s charm — it’s got the perfect balance of laid-back beach vibes and easy access to everything you’ll want to do.

The beach is right there, of course, but the surrounding area has a lot more to offer, too. We loved how everything was within walking distance: from the beach to great little restaurants, shops, and places to grab a drink.

There’s a mix of hotels and resorts here, so whether you’re after a condo with a view or a cozy resort with a pool, you’ll find something that fits.

Best Hotels in Siesta Beach

Siesta Key Beach Resort

This place is steps from the beach, which makes it a great spot for first-timers. You’ll have a pool to chill at, plus a fully equipped kitchen if you’re in the mood to cook. It’s pretty laid-back, but it still feels special.

► Click here for more information & bookings

Tropical Breeze Resort

Another good choice if you want something close to the beach but with a bit more of a homey feel. It’s got all the basics — a heated pool, beach chairs, and a quick walk to the sand. Super easy to feel at home here.

► Click here for more information & bookings

Things to Do in Siesta Beach

• The beach itself is, of course, the main attraction. We spent hours lounging in the sand, cooling off in the water, and just enjoying the view. We would also sometimes rent one of these funny looking cars (Scoot Coupes) from Robin Hood Rentals and just drive around for a day, so much fun!
• Siesta Key Village is just a short walk from the beach, and it’s full of cute shops, bars, and casual restaurants. We loved grabbing lunch at one of the local spots, doing a bit of shopping, and then relaxing with a drink by the water.
• And of course, the sunset here is not to be missed. We made it a point to head to the beach in the evening to watch the sky change colors as the sun set.
• Join a scenic sunset tour by e-bike. It’s a super cool way to explore the island and catch the best sunset spots.
• Head to the Sun Garden Cafe. It’s our favorite breakfast and lunch spot, and they have a super cute outdoor seating area as well.

2.Siesta Key Village – Best Place to Stay in Siesta Key for Nightlife

If you’re someone who enjoys a little nightlife on vacation, Siesta Key Village is where you want to stay.

It’s the heart of the island’s nightlife and the island’s downtown area. You’ll find a great mix of places to grab a drink, enjoy live music, or just hang out with friends.

What’s awesome is how everything is within walking distance — no need to worry about driving or finding parking. That’s one thing we love about Siesta Key in general — you don’t even need a car.

This area is perfect if you want to enjoy some nighttime fun but still be close to the beach.

Best Hotels in Siesta Key Village

Siesta Key Oasis

Siesta Key Oasis is an amazing and affordable holiday home for up to 12 people, featuring 4 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. It includes a private pool, hot tub, and BBQ area for relaxing nights in. It’s perfect for families or a group of friends who want to stay in the downtown area.

► Click here for more information & bookings

Sea Spray Resort

For a more traditional hotel experience, check out the Sea Spray Resort. It offers cozy rooms and cottages just steps away from the village. The resort features an outdoor swimming pool, free private parking, a BBQ area, and family rooms.

► Click here for more information & bookings

Canal 313

A small-bedroom beachfront condo perfect for couples or solo travelers, Canal 313 is a cozy and modern accommodation located just steps away from Siesta Key Village. It features a private pool and an outdoor seating area.

► Click here for more information & bookings

Things to Do in Siesta Key Village

• The village has plenty of quirky stores and boutiques to check out during the day. My favorite is Casa Del Sol Boutique; they have loads of cute outfits.
• Siesta Key Village is home to a great selection of bars where you can enjoy craft cocktails or casual beers with a fun crowd. The Cottage is our go-to for cheap drinks and live music.
• Stop by the Daiquiri Deck. It’s a local favorite for drinks and casual vibes. Another great spot for happy hour and live music.
• Sarasota Mangrove Night Tour

3.Where to Stay in Siesta Key, Florida for Families: Siesta Key’s Crescent Beach

If you’re traveling with kids, Crescent Beach in Siesta Key is the best area to stay in Siesta Key.

The beach is less crowded than Siesta Beach, making it an ideal spot for those who prefer a slower pace. The soft sand and shallow waters provide a safe environment for children to enjoy the waves without the usual rush of people.

We spent quite some time here because we loved the quieter atmosphere. There are also plenty of holiday homes and family-friendly resorts in the area.

Best Hotels in Siesta Key’s Crescent Beach

Tropical Beach Resorts

This little beach resort is located right on the beach, is super cozy, and has a great family vibe. It offers all the comforts you need—the beach is just across the street. They have a heated pool and complimentary beach chairs, perfect for sitting on the white crystal sands. Just make sure you have confirmed availability because it gets busy, especially during high season.

► Click here for more information & bookings

Captiva Beach Resort

Captiva Beach Resort definitely gets extra points for its private beach access and fantastic location. They offer small apartments that usually come with a full kitchen, which I like because I often enjoy cooking, especially when I’m traveling with a group or family.

► Click here for more information & bookings

Excelsior Beach to Bay-Bayside

If you’re looking for a full-size vacation home, this condo is the perfect fit. It’s situated right on the bay, offering stunning views and access to tennis courts, and it’s also conveniently close to Sarasota. The condo comes fully equipped with everything you need, from a spacious kitchen to multiple bedrooms, making it ideal for larger groups.

► Click here for more information & bookings

Things to Do in Siesta Key’s Crescent Beach

• Join Fun Boat Tours for exciting dolphin tours! Choose from Dolphin and Donuts for breakfast, Dolphin and Drinks in the afternoon, or a Sunset Dolphin Cruise.
• Enjoy delicious seafood at Captain Curt’s Crab and Oyster Bar.

4.Where to Stay in Siesta Key on a Budget : Sarasota

When you are visiting Siesta Key and want to keep things easy on the wallet, Sarasota is the way to go.

I know it’s technically not on Siesta Key, but it’s just a short drive away, so you’re not far from the island’s best beaches and all the fun.

What we loved about staying in Sarasota is how relaxed it feels—like you’re still close to the action but with a bit more of a local, laid-back vibe. Plus, it’s a lot more affordable than staying right on Siesta Key itself.

We spent a few nights in Sarasota and were pleasantly surprised by how much it had to offer. From affordable hotels to charming streets lined with shops and cafes, it’s a great base for exploring Siesta Key without breaking the bank.

Best Hotels in Sarasota

Lido Beach Resort

Located just a short 10-minute drive from Siesta Key, Lido Beach Resort offers affordable and comfortable accommodation with stunning views of the ocean. The resort has a private beach, multiple pools, and an on-site restaurant for convenient dining options. And if you want to explore more of Sarasota, the resort provides complimentary shuttle service to nearby attractions.

► Click here for more information & bookings

Hampton Inn & Suites Sarasota

hampton inn is a geat chice for a solid stay near the Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport, which is about a 15-minute drive from Siesta Key. The hotel offers spacious and comfortable rooms, complimentary breakfast, and an outdoor pool for guests to enjoy.

► Click here for more information & bookings

Siesta Key Palms Resort

My personal favorite for a relaxing and luxurious stay on Siesta Key is the Siesta Key Palms Resort. This boutique hotel offers beautifully decorated rooms, private beach access, and a tropical pool area with hammocks and a tiki bar.

► Click here for more information & bookings

Things to Do in Sarasota

• The Ringling Museum offers impressive art exhibits in a beautiful setting.
• St. Armands Circle has boutique shops, cafes, and great people-watching.
• Myakka River State Park is ideal for hiking or enjoying nature.
• The Sarasota Opera House hosts excellent performances in a stunning venue.
• Take a day trip to Anna Maria Island – Check out our Anna Maria Island Guide

FAQ about Finding a Place to Stay in Siesta Key

What is the best resort in Siesta Key?

I know Lido Beach Resort is technically not in Siesta Key, but if you don’t care too much about the location, have a rental car, or just want to relax on the beach, Lido Beach Resort is the best when it comes to value for money. It’s a beautiful resort with modern amenities and private beach access.

Are there any affordable accommodation options in Siesta Key?

Yes, absolutely! There are loads of different cheap hotels and holiday homes. Some of our favorite affordable Siesta Key accommodations are:

Final Thoughts on the Best Places to Stay in Siesta Key Florida

Siesta Key is one of those places that feels made for relaxation, yet it offers plenty of activities to keep things interesting, no matter what kind of getaway you’re looking for.

Whether you’re a first-timer seeking easy beach access, a couple looking for nightlife, or a family wanting a quiet retreat by the water, you’re guaranteed to find the perfect spot for you.

We loved how each neighborhood offers a unique vibe—head to the Village for dinner and drinks, or choose the south end for a peaceful family vacation. I hope this guide on where to stay in Siesta Key, Florida, helps you plan your perfect trip!

Related Articles